The Case For Marriage

Categories:

Ah, July, the wedding season. What a great time of the year to NOT marry.

So suggest Jessica Bennett and Jesse Ellison in the June 11 edition of Newsweek magazine.

The two young, urban women write that marriage no longer makes sense — they cite an anthropologist who says humans are wired for a series of relationships over time.

Cartoon by Nate Beeler - Washington Examiner (click to purchase)
Cartoon by Nate Beeler – Washington Examiner (click to purchase)

They say that, thanks to the feminist movement, women no longer need husbands for financial security.

They say that divorce rates are high — that with our life expectancy into the high 70s it is unrealistic to commit to one other person for life.

They cite all kinds of statistics and anecdotes to document why they believe marriage no longer works.

Of course they’re looking at the institution of marriage from the vantage point of youth. When you get older, you realize most people are better off married.

Men who are single too long are a scourge on society. We take chances, eat badly, smoke too much and are far likelier than married men to wake in a pile of newspapers still clutching the bottle of tequila we began sipping from just before the party broke up.

We forget important dates — we arrive at our parents’ 50th wedding anniversary a week AFTER the celebration occurred.

Single women do better, but not a lot better. The longer they go without marrying — the more relationships they pass through in their pursuit of the perfect man — the more cynical and disappointed they will become.

The average male can barely drink a beer and rub his belly at the same time. How the heck can he ever fulfill the job requirements of “soulmate?”

The women who penned the Newsweek article believe we have been liberated by our enlightened, progressive era — our era of unlimited choice and freedom.

I think the opposite is mostly true. With all our wealth, you see — the recession notwithstanding — we are strangled by choice.

When we wake in the morning, we choose among hundreds of breakfast cereals, drinks, coffees, toothpastes, shampoos, towels, clothes …

Picking out a lousy pair of blue jeans — stone-washed, acid-washed, relaxed fit — can take an entire Saturday if you’re nutty enough to allow it.

And now we’re applying the same approach to dating, relationships and marriage in our fruitless search for our “soulmates?”

Sorry, but there is no soulmate, this lazy sense that someone will enter your life and keep you in a perpetual state of bliss.

Isn’t human love as much the result of work, commitment, kindness and sacrifice as it is chemistry or dumb luck?

Unlimited choice — holding out for our soulmates — isn’t making us happy. It is making us miserable.

Rather, the act of making, and sticking by, a decision to love and care for someone — before your family, your community and your God — is the only way meaningful happiness can be found.

G.K. Chesterton said marriage brings a man and woman happiness because it limits their choice.

Could you imagine being an artist, he said, who is trying to paint a canvas as large as the moon? Where do you start painting?

By being boxed into a small rectangular area, the artist gains a point of reference and perspective. It is the frame that sets the artist free.

That is what marriage ultimately is: a decision. We’ve become a nation of adolescents, with unrealistic expectations, who aren’t much in the mood to make adult decisions.

The authors of the Newsweek article are trying to paint the moon. It’s just a matter of time, as I have learned, before they run out of paint.

—–

©2010 Tom Purcell. Tom Purcell, a freelance writer is also a humor columnist for the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, and is nationally syndicated exclusively by Cagle Cartoons newspaper syndicate. For more info contact Cari Dawson Bartley at 800 696 7561 or email [email protected]. Visit Tom on the web at www.TomPurcell.com or e-mail him at [email protected].


Comments

7 responses to “The Case For Marriage”

  1. geoff Avatar

    Not that it has anything to do with marriage (given that she is supposed to have had an affair with her husband's ex-business partner and has a daughter who is a single mother), but… it's possibly a question whether the enhancement was for marital or professional reasons:

    "An Irish gambling website has placed odds on whether the skanky former half-term governor of Alaska, Sarah Palin, will admit that she had a boob job before the 2012 election.

    "Paddy Power is offering odds on Palin’s cup size for the presidential election, with odds of 20/1 on an A/B cup, 4/6 on a C cup, 2/1 on an E cup and 25/1 on an F Cup or above.

    "The cheecky website is also wondering what Palin’s next surgical procedure will be, try Botox (4/6), lip collagen injections (9/4), liposuction (5/1) or a face lift (10/1)."

    More here: http://www.gamblingkingz.com/news/2010/06/22/odds

  2. Nykya Avatar
    Nykya

    "Isn’t human love as much the result of work, commitment, kindness and sacrifice as it is chemistry or dumb luck?"

    But marriage isn't the only form of human love & it certainly isn't the only pathway to happiness. There are many Americans who've made the adult (not adolescent) choice to analyze marriage from all sides and decide it is not right for them. Who are we to judge them as childish & immature? Marriage is not for everyone, and we really need to leave alone those who have consciously chosen this path. Seriously.

    I was hoping this artcle would plead the case for marriage. Unfortunately, all I got was you-single-people-are-destroying-America routine. But if you do decide to plead your case, I'm willing to listen.

  3. Good Life Avatar
    Good Life

    The newest research says love is an addiction.

    http://www.livescience.com/culture/romantic-rejec

  4. Casey Avatar
    Casey

    I completely agree with this article (even if I'm one of those single people of America)

    Women no longer need husbands for financial security, divorce rates are high, it is quite an undertaking to commit to another person for life, and sometimes marriage doesn't work for two people.

    But take a look at those couples celebrating their 30th, 40th, or 50th wedding anniversaries. Marriage does work. And it does teach commitment, sacrifice, and the real effort love requires. I think it's a cop out to say that people are literally unable to commit to someone for that length of time.

  5. WMDFail Avatar
    WMDFail

    I guess, achievement in both areas of life is pretty important.

    professionally and personally.

    Both have to be in balance. I assume.

    @Casey

    "But take a look at those couples celebrating their 30th, 40th, or 50th wedding anniversaries"

    Yes, they should give out medals for this.

  6. Forward78 Avatar
    Forward78

    Attributes such as commitment, sacrifice, and the "effort" to love are not learned in a marriage. Either you have those characteristcs or you don't. Hateful people can marry. Loving people can marry. Generous people can marry. Selfish people can marry. Marriage all by itself is not some mystical force that makes you a better person. If one wishes to be better, then one must make the effort to be better, married or not.

    My parents (who've been married over 30 years) have had the kind of marriage I would not wish on my worst enemy. But, you wouldn't know it if you saw them. I won't re-live all the painful things I've seen growing up in that house. I just vowed to never be like them. But all people see is "Wow. they've been together so long!"

    the point: Good marriages work. Bad ones are Hell on Earth. Whether they are Heaven or Hell isn't up to marriage itself, but it's up to those involved.

  7. mole Avatar
    mole

    "Rather, the act of making, and sticking by, a decision to love and care for someone — before your family, your community and your God — is the only way meaningful happiness can be found."

    The ONLY way? Do you have any reason to make this statement, other than it is what YOU say?

    Do you ever work with facts. I know many married couples who share true happiness. I also know a few who are totally miserable. And I know single men and women who want nothing else. But if YOU say it's the ONLY way, then who can argue with you? Must be true, I guess.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *